Cheap Flights from New York, NY to Indianapolis, IN from $87

On Cheapflightsplus.com you will find 1 direct and 147 connecting flights from New York to Indianapolis. You can compare airfare deals from 5 airlines and multiple travel sites from $87, book and save on cheap plane tickets and last minute offers. Also check out NYC-IND flight schedule to find best flight time, convenient departure and arrival airports.

Find One-Way and Round-Trip New York to Indianapolis Flight Deals

To find the cheapest one way airline ticket select the date with the lowest price on the calendar below and click «Find Flights». To search for round-trip flight deals click on the link «Check prices for return flights» and select the date of the return flight. Cheapest flights in November: $87 (one-way), $149 (round-trip).
Direct flights
  • Check to choose departure date Check to choose departure date
Check prices for return flight
Find flights
Full flight schedule will help you in detecting at what time planes fly from New York to Indianapolis. You can also specify the concrete flights and airlines on the route and how long the flight actually is. Use the calendar for today, tomorrow or other specific date as some flights are available only on certain days of the week.
Departure Arrival Flight Details Flight Duration Price
10:26 — 12:46
10:26 — 12:46 NK317 Spirit Airlines
New York — Indianapolis
2h 20m
Find flight
from$87
05:55 — 08:50
+1 day
05:55 — 08:45 NK2474 Spirit Airlines
New York — Sanford
21h 50m stop
06:35 — 08:50 G42910 Allegiant Air
Sanford — Indianapolis
26h 55m
including layover
Find flight
from$161
06:00 — 16:40
06:00 — 08:57 NK1350 Spirit Airlines
New York — Orlando
5h 16m stop
14:13 — 16:40 NK2890 Spirit Airlines
Orlando — Indianapolis
10h 40m
including layover
Find flight
from$107
06:59 — 09:20
+1 day
06:59 — 09:50 NK1571 Spirit Airlines
New York — Orlando
21h 10m stop
07:00 — 09:20 NK1510 Spirit Airlines
Orlando — Indianapolis
26h 21m
including layover
Find flight
from$126
07:20 — 15:18
07:20 — 08:57 UA561 United Airlines
New York — Chicago
4h 8m stop
13:05 — 15:18 UA3571 United Airlines
Chicago — Indianapolis
7h 58m
including layover
Find flight
from$254
08:30 — 17:42
08:30 — 10:28 NK2422 Spirit Airlines
New York — Charlotte
5h 30m stop
18:38 — 20:19 NK2362 Spirit Airlines
Charlotte — Indianapolis
9h 12m
including layover
Find flight
from$188
08:42 — 16:35
08:42 — 10:45 NK1717 Spirit Airlines
New York — Charlotte
4h 11m stop
14:56 — 16:35 NK1125 Spirit Airlines
Charlotte — Indianapolis
7h 53m
including layover
Find flight
from$116
09:00 — 14:39
09:00 — 11:40 F91871 Frontier Airlines
New York — Atlanta
1h 26m stop
13:08 — 14:44 F92497 Frontier Airlines
Atlanta — Indianapolis
5h 39m
including layover
Find flight
from$194
09:55 — 15:47
+1 day
09:55 — 12:48 NK2707 Spirit Airlines
New York — Dallas
23h 52m stop
12:40 — 15:47 NK2729 Spirit Airlines
Dallas — Indianapolis
29h 52m
including layover
Find flight
from$141
11:30 — 16:46
+1 day
11:10 — 14:10 F94057 Frontier Airlines
New York — Tampa
23h 50m stop
14:06 — 16:30 F94959 Frontier Airlines
Tampa — Indianapolis
29h 16m
including layover
Find flight
from$150
15:25 — 23:31
15:25 — 17:02 UA1504 United Airlines
New York — Chicago
4h 10m stop
21:12 — 23:31 UA3526 United Airlines
Chicago — Indianapolis
8h 6m
including layover
Find flight
from$201
16:46 — 13:30
+1 day
16:46 — 18:46 NK1403 Spirit Airlines
New York — Charlotte
17h 2m stop
11:48 — 13:30 NK2363 Spirit Airlines
Charlotte — Indianapolis
20h 44m
including layover
Find flight
from$180
16:56 — 09:46
+1 day
16:56 — 20:09 NK3396 Spirit Airlines
New York — Miami
10h 51m stop
07:00 — 09:46 NK271 Spirit Airlines
Miami — Indianapolis
16h 50m
including layover
Find flight
from$156
18:48 — 20:22
+1 day
18:48 — 21:47 NK475 Spirit Airlines
New York — Sanford
20h 18m stop
18:05 — 20:22 G41274 Allegiant Air
Sanford — Indianapolis
25h 34m
including layover
Find flight
from$110
18:48 — 20:43
+1 day
18:48 — 21:47 NK475 Spirit Airlines
New York — Orlando
20h 28m stop
18:15 — 20:43 NK1944 Spirit Airlines
Orlando — Indianapolis
25h 55m
including layover
Find flight
from$130
21:05 — 20:34
+1 day
21:05 — 00:06 NK475 Spirit Airlines
New York — Sanford
18h 10m stop
18:16 — 20:34 G4593 Allegiant Air
Sanford — Indianapolis
23h 29m
including layover
Find flight
from$131
22:55 — 00:43
+2 days
22:55 — 01:15 F93161 Frontier Airlines
New York — Denver
18h 54m stop
20:09 — 00:43 F92346 Frontier Airlines
Denver — Indianapolis
25h 48m
including layover
Find flight
from$102
22:55 — 12:15
+1 day
22:55 — 01:17 F93161 Frontier Airlines
New York — Denver
6h 28m stop
10:59 — 15:34 F92348 Frontier Airlines
Denver — Indianapolis
13h 20m
including layover
Find flight
from$124
05:46 — 23:03
05:46 — 08:58 NK1172 Spirit Airlines
New York — Houston
1h 5m stop
10:03 — 13:06 NK1748 Spirit Airlines
Houston — Clearwater
7h 42m stop
20:48 — 23:03 G4624 Allegiant Air
Clearwater — Indianapolis
17h 17m
including layover
Find flight
from$170
10:53 — 14:26
+1 day
10:53 — 12:52 NK2494 Spirit Airlines
New York — Detroit
6h 4m stop
18:56 — 21:31 NK2083 Spirit Airlines
Detroit — Clearwater
14h 34m stop
12:05 — 14:26 G42231 Allegiant Air
Clearwater — Indianapolis
27h 33m
including layover
Find flight
from$190
11:53 — 18:12
+1 day
11:53 — 13:54 NK2494 Spirit Airlines
New York — Detroit
56m stop
14:50 — 16:51 NK1159 Spirit Airlines
Detroit — Atlanta
23h 56m stop
16:47 — 18:12 NK1115 Spirit Airlines
Atlanta — Indianapolis
30h 19m
including layover
Find flight
from$158
12:55 — 08:15
+1 day
12:55 — 14:56 NK382 Spirit Airlines
New York — Detroit
4h stop
18:56 — 21:31 NK2083 Spirit Airlines
Detroit — Tampa
8h 29m stop
06:00 — 08:15 NK3915 Spirit Airlines
Tampa — Indianapolis
19h 20m
including layover
Find flight
from$190
12:55 — 14:26
+1 day
12:55 — 14:56 NK382 Spirit Airlines
New York — Detroit
4h stop
18:56 — 21:31 NK2083 Spirit Airlines
Detroit — Clearwater
14h 34m stop
12:05 — 14:26 G42231 Allegiant Air
Clearwater — Indianapolis
25h 31m
including layover
Find flight
from$190
13:30 — 09:20
+1 day
13:30 — 16:29 NK1692 Spirit Airlines
New York — Dallas
1h 1m stop
17:30 — 21:13 NK1697 Spirit Airlines
Dallas — Orlando
9h 47m stop
07:00 — 09:20 NK1510 Spirit Airlines
Orlando — Indianapolis
19h 50m
including layover
Find flight
from$219
15:13 — 09:20
+1 day
15:13 — 17:09 NK1092 Spirit Airlines
New York — Columbus
4h 8m stop
21:17 — 23:32 NK1531 Spirit Airlines
Columbus — Orlando
7h 28m stop
07:00 — 09:20 NK1510 Spirit Airlines
Orlando — Indianapolis
18h 7m
including layover
Find flight
from$229
19:55 — 11:52
+1 day
19:59 — 23:03 NK2281 Spirit Airlines
New York — Miami
7h 5m stop
06:00 — 07:07 NK2195 Spirit Airlines
Miami — Orlando
2h 15m stop
09:51 — 12:20 NK2480 Spirit Airlines
Orlando — Indianapolis
15h 57m
including layover
Find flight
from$240
21:27 — 20:22
+1 day
21:27 — 23:29 NK3392 Spirit Airlines
New York — Detroit
6h 31m stop
06:00 — 08:41 NK3780 Spirit Airlines
Detroit — Sanford
9h 24m stop
18:05 — 20:22 G41274 Allegiant Air
Sanford — Indianapolis
22h 55m
including layover
Find flight
from$152
*Departure and arrival times - local. Updated on July 6, 2025

Flight Information

Below we will explain in detail what the flights cost on the destination from New York to Indianapolis depends on and how to choose the most interesting flight option for you.

Distance between New York and Indianapolis is 1048 miles. Time difference between the cities is 0h. Airplanes depart 05:46 to 22:55 from 16 New York airports and arrive 05:46 to 22:55 to 1 Indianapolis airport. Average flight time is 2h 20m.

  • The fastest flight 2h 20m
  • Average flight time 2h 20m
  • The earliest flight 05:46
  • The latest flight 22:55
  • Distance 652 ml

The cheapest months to travel to Indianapolis are september (from 87 $), july (from 102 $), august (from 107 $).

The most expensive months are february (from 190 $), january (from 190 $), may (from 171 $).

What is the lowest airfare New York to Indianapolis?

The cheapest plane ticket found by our users is $87. This airfare is for economy class on one-way NK317 flight by Spirit Airlines for September 27, 2025 which leaves La Guardia in New York at 10:26 am and arrives at Indianapolis Indianapolis Int. at 12:46.

Economy class
$87
Find
Business class
?
Find
First class
?
Find

Popular Airlines on the Route

The flight New York — Indianapolis is served by 5 regular airlines and 2 low-cost airlines. Most of the flights on this route are operated by Alaska Airlines - 1 departures per week at the price of from $ 384 . And the most expensive tickets are offered by United Airlines airline - from $ 425.

Direct flights

There are 1 nonstop flights on the route. The fastest direct flight is NK317 by Spirit Airlines takes 2h 20m and the cheapest is NK317 by Spirit Airlines for $87.

  • NK - Spirit Airlines
    from $87
    Find
See more direct flights

Connecting Flights

There are 147 flights with layovers on the route. The fastest connecting flight is UA3688 by United Airlines takes 3h 53m and the cheapest is NK317 by Spirit Airlines for $102.

  • AS - Alaska Airlines
    from $384
    Find
  • F9 - Frontier Airlines
    from $102
    Find
  • HA - Hawaiian Airlines
    from $304
    Find
  • UA - United Airlines
    from $190
    Find
  • NK - Spirit Airlines
    from $107
    Find
See more connecting flights

Airports

You can fly from New York to Indianapolis from 16 airports (39th Street Ferry, Newyork Airport, Newyork Airport, La Guardia, Westchester County, World Trade Center, Pier 11/Wall St. SPB, John F Kennedy Intl, Flushing, East 34th St Heliport, West 30th St Heliport, Downtown Manhattan H/p, East 60th Street H/P, Battery Pk City/N. Cov, East 34th St Landing, Marine Air Terminal).

New York airports

  • 39th Street Ferry-XNY
    Find
  • Newyork Airport-NWK
    Find
  • Newyork Airport-NYP
    Find
  • La Guardia-LGA
    from $87
    Find
  • Westchester County-HPN
    Find
  • World Trade Center-WTC
    Find
  • Pier 11/Wall St. SPB-NWS
    Find
  • John F Kennedy Intl-JFK
    from $150
    Find
  • Flushing-FLU
    Find
  • East 34th St Heliport-TSS
    Find
  • West 30th St Heliport-JRA
    Find
  • Downtown Manhattan H/p-JRB
    Find
  • East 60th Street H/P-JRE
    Find
  • Battery Pk City/N. Cov-NBP
    Find
  • East 34th St Landing-NES
    Find
  • Marine Air Terminal-QNY
    Find

Indianapolis airports

  • Indianapolis Int.-IND
    Find

How to book a plane ticket yourself?

How to book an air ticket yourself?
  • Fill in the search parameters — cities of departure and destination, departure and return dates and click «Find flights»
  • Select the best flight that you like. Please, check the airports of departure and arrival. Select the best fare, but pay attention to the following flight details - airports of departure and arrival, flight duration and layovers. Please use filters and sort to find the best flight.
  • Click «Buy» when you are ready — our system will redirect you to the site that sells the selected flight ticket.
  • Fill in all passenger and payment information — passport and contact information, please double check all passengers’ names and make a payment for your itinerary.
  • That's it — you will receive an email with your e-ticket usually within 10 minutes after your flight is confirmed. Please, print the e-ticket and have it with you at the airport. You would need to have only a passport and/or a required form of ID to travel. Please, check your Visa requirements if you travel outside of the United States or Canada.

    To find a plane ticket, please select dates.

Back